AITAH for buying my girlfriend vanilla shampoo?

AITAH for buying my girlfriend vanilla shampoo?

My girlfriend uses a few different types of shampoo and alternates between them. One of them, a vanilla scented one, is my favorite. She asked me to pick up some things for her at the store, and on my way to check out I saw the vanilla shampoo and grabbed that too. When I got back to her apartment, she started putting away the things I bought. She was confused by the shampoo and asked me why I got it.
I said that I saw it and know she uses that kind and grabbed it for her. She said she wasn’t running low on shampoo. I said I know, but it doesn’t expire and that one is my favorite. I teasingly said that she should use it if she’s planning to wash her hair tonight. She asked what I meant by it being my “favorite.” I said I like the way it makes her hair smell, like cookies.
She looked a little weirded out. I asked her if she was okay. She said it was weird that I sexualized her shampoo. I said smelling nice is sexy. I asked if she thinks I’m sexier when I used nice smelling soaps and deodorants. She said not really, as long as I don’t actively smell bad. I said maybe it’s different for everyone.
She said honestly it bothered her that something as mundane as shampoo was sexual to me. She asked me if someone else smelled like vanilla would I be attracted to them? I said no, that she was misunderstanding me. She asked me to clarify, but I don’t think I did a good job. I said I specifically like the smell on her, not other people. She still seemed put out, so I headed home to give her space.
Was I an asshole for buying the shampoo and telling her I like when she uses it? To me that’s not weird, but maybe that’s because I’m a guy. Is there a layer to this I’m not seeing?

This is other people OP:

I would’ve thought it was sexy and cute. You’re not the AH at all.

The most romantic thing my husband did for me was buy me a personal pizza with olives on it because I told him I like it but hadn’t ordered one in years because I just eat what everyone else likes and they don’t like olives. We were talking about something else and I just casually mentioned it as an aside. Three weeks later I came home and it was sitting on our kitchen island with a heart drawn on the box.

It wasn’t the pizza. It was confirmation that he was listening to me and not just paying attention to his phone.

Being attentive is important.

I thought I was being sexy and cute too! She’s my first real relationship, so I acknowledge that I’m inexperienced here, but I thought it was a very innocent way to flirt. It’s not like I bought her underwear.

It’s a very very cute way to flirt. Don’t be disheartened and make sure you do it for your next GF, she’ll love it.

She’s kind of rude and awful. That was sweet and you find her sexy and the scent reminds you of her.

1.5K

NTA. What on earth? You did something nice. She should have said thank you. My husband comments if he likes my perfume. She presumably buys the vanilla scented shampoo because she also likes the smell. Making it out like you’re some weird freak for also liking the smell is wild. It’s like she was looking for something to fight about.

Yeah, I don’t get it. Liking certain smells is normal, right? Isn’t that the point of scented things? And perfume? It’s not a creepy thing to like.

I had a partner who specifically loved when I used green tea scented products.

Knowing that was a boost for me, and even though we’re not together now, I still feel a boost with that scent.

Exactly! The entire perfume industry is based on…what again?

It’s beyond normal. It’s so normal, we shouldn’t be having this conversation. Either this is some really bad attempt at gaslighting or she’s legit got a screw loose.

Your girlfriend is a bit of an ungrateful loon. You showed her that you pay attention to her and the brands she uses AND that you like how she smells and she finds a way to make this weird? I don’t like your girlfriend

Edit: Thank you for the award, fellow redditor:)

Your girlfriend certainly is for making it weird.

some people are desperate to find red flags that they end up becoming one istg

This is what some people do when they want to break up, they take the smallest things and make it into something massive.

what do you think??

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *