AITAH for refusing to tell my wife I love her more than my dad?

AITAH for refusing to tell my wife I love her more than my dad?

This is a stupid argument, but we both think we’re right, so I’ll let Reddit decide. My dad babysat for us last night so we could go on a date. I picked him up and drove him over because he avoids driving at night these days. My wife and I said to put the baby down for the evening by eight.
When we got back my dad was sitting on the couch holding our (sleeping) baby. He said he was sorry he wasn’t in the crib but that he fussed whenever he tried to put him in the crib so he just gave up and held him. My wife was upset, and it was obvious. I took the baby to put him in the crib. When I went back into the living room they were whisper arguing.
I told dad we should head back. He got in the car, and I drove him home. He apologized for not putting the baby in the crib and said he was very fussy and probably just missed us and was anxious we weren’t the ones putting him down. I said he was probably right and it was no big deal.
When I got home my wife was still upset. She asked me what my dad said about her. I said he didn’t say anything about her, just apologized and said the baby probably missed us. My wife said he won’t adjust to his sleep schedule unless it is consistent. I agreed with her and said it’s been a long time since my dad took care of a baby, so we should cut him some slack. She asked why I was taking his side over hers. I said I’m not, but that we had a great night, and I didn’t want us to let something minor ruin it. She said it isn’t minor, and I’m supposed to back her up, not gossip about her with my dad. I said I didn’t gossip about her. All I did was drive him home. She asked why I drove him home when she was clearly upset. I asked what else I was supposed to do. She said I could have ordered a rideshare or a cab. I said the plan was always for me to drive him home. She said “right, because we have to stick with the almighty plan.” I asked her why she didn’t just tell me she wanted me to do something different. She asked if I would have if she asked me to. I said I wasn’t sure (because of the cost and time delay). She said exactly. I said we could have talked about it though. She said I’m always trying to sit on the fence when I should be on her field. I said I am on her field. She asked who I love more, her or my dad. I said that was a crazy question and I wasn’t going to answer it. She said she needed to know. I said I don’t rank people I love. I love my wife as a wife and my dad as a dad. She says I’m an asshole for not choosing her. I say I’m not, because I don’t think love is a numbered list like some kind of WatchMojo video.

Here’s what people had to say

Not even strategic in a sly way, but absolutely reasonable. He did the dirt why should you have to put yourself out financially by immediately ending the relationship at the time he cheated. That’s going to cost you a huge amount in upheaval to your life. He thinks you should have shouldered that cost based on idiot logic.

He believes he should be immune to consequences of his actions and believes everyone else should be put out instead. And if I was to try and sum up everything that’s wrong in the world in terms of geopolitics right now I couldn’t do it better than that.

and it’s not like she was directly taking from him. she paid all of her roomate costs and did all of the homecare that he was used to while slowly stepping away from the relationship. saving up money on the side is different than draining a joint account suddenly.

NTA, you had an exit strategy and left on your terms. Perfect. Cheaters don’t deserve honor or consideration. As for you blindsiding him? Lol, did he forget he was fucking another woman while being your BF? The mutuals who thinks you messed up his relationship? Fuck them. Call them out for being idiots and then cut them off.

I would asked the other woman if she knew about you right to her face. That happened to my cousin, btw. This lady walked up to her and her cheating scum BF and asked her if she knew he was married. In a crowded restaurant. Dude bolted. Cousin told her she didn’t know and dumped the guy.

Definitely NTA. Wow, this is honestly amazing. I’m super impressed you held it together those months. Good on you for saving so much, times are tough and you’ll need it.

NTA. I am APPLAUDING YOU!

Oh, he’s embarrassed??

Maybe don’t be a lying, cheating, dicksnippet then, moron.

The fact that he has the gall to try and turn any of this around onto you, and that anyone would even entertain it for a second is ASININE.

You didn’t use him or even harm him, you OUTSMARTED HIM. You turned his lying/cheating, shitty behavior into a way to protect yourself, and went about your business until you could cleanly exit.

He was just pissy because you beat him at his own game- he couldn’t continue USING YOU as a backup plan/steady roommate.

What an absolute loser. I hope that Maggie dumped him and told everyone that would listen what a joke he is. I hope you’re out there living your best life. BRAVA, OP.

NTA. You were smart and did well, as a guy that hate cheating I’ll say well played. Hope everything turns out well for you and the next guy you meet is a faithful decent one

Not him trying to claim he was “blindsided” by you leaving when you guys haven’t been intimate or romantic for months.
Men really do think we’ll stay through anything.
NTA You did what you had to do to move out, nothing wrong with that.

I’m glad you said something, the other woman deserves to know she was being lied to and cheated on for months.

 

what do you think ??

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *