PART 3: THE RECORDING HE COULDN’T ERASE
“Yesterday.”
I said the word again because I needed someone else to hear how impossible it was.
My name sat beneath a description of something that hadn’t happened until tonight.
Something that hadn’t happened the way the paper claimed at all.
Detective Ortiz lowered the document.
“Faye, look at me.”
I tried.
“Have you ever seen this page before?”
“No.”
“Did anyone ask you to sign a statement about hurting your sister?”
“No.”
Across the narrow space between our beds, Chloe began shaking.
“That wasn’t the page she showed me.”
Ortiz turned toward her.
“What was different?”
“The words. There was something about money on mine.”
Chloe looked at me.
“But your signature was already on another sheet underneath.”
A memory surfaced so suddenly that I almost sat up.
Brenda leaning over our kitchen table.
A school permission slip beneath my hand.
“Your signature is getting sloppy, Faye. Write it properly.”
She had made me sign a second time.
Then a third.
That had been two weeks ago.
I told Ortiz.
She wrote it down without promising what it meant.
Somehow, I trusted her more for that.
She didn’t tell us everything was solved. She didn’t say one piece of paper would make the rest easy.
She said, “We’ll need to establish where these documents came from.”
Then she asked a nurse to make sure nobody admitted visitors without checking with us and the care team.
“Even our mother?” Chloe whispered.
“Especially if you don’t want her here.”
Chloe nodded.
I watched her shoulders lower a fraction.
For years, every door in our house had belonged to someone else.
For the first time, we had a say in who came through one.
An hour later, a hospital social worker named Miriam arrived with a laptop and a cup of water I couldn’t stop spilling.
She replaced it with one that had a lid.
She didn’t comment on my trembling hands.
Ortiz sat beside her.
“You mentioned the online account,” she said. “Do you feel well enough to help us find it?”
I nodded.
Remembering the password was easy.
Typing it was not.
Dad had made it a sentence from a bedtime story he used to tell us, with numbers tucked into places only we would remember.
My fingers paused above the keyboard.
For one second, I could hear his voice.
Two little foxes. One enormous forest.
“Faye?” Chloe whispered.
“I remember.”
The account opened.
There were folders I hadn’t looked at since before Dad died.
Birthday pictures.
Tax records.
A blurry video of Chloe trying to teach our old dog to shake hands.
Then I saw the folder I had created three months earlier.
Heating.
A boring name.
Something Edric would scroll past if he ever got into the account.
I clicked it.
Rows of audio files appeared.
Dates.
Times.
Lengths.
Some were only minutes long. Others lasted hours because I had been too frightened to crawl across the floor and stop the recording.
Miriam moved her chair closer.
“You don’t have to listen to these right now,” she said.
Ortiz nodded.
“With your permission, we can arrange to preserve them and review them separately.”
“Please.”
The word escaped before she finished.
I had made those recordings because I wanted someone to know.
I had never thought about what it would feel like to hear them.
Ortiz began noting the account information and the names of the files.
Then Chloe leaned forward.
“Wait.”
Her eyes had fixed on one date.
“The Thursday one.”
“Which Thursday?” I asked.
“The day Mom took us to the dentist.”
I found it.
The recording was more than four hours long.
That morning, I had left the phone running under the floorboard because Edric had been pacing outside our room before breakfast.
Then Brenda had unexpectedly told us to put on our shoes.
I remembered being grateful to leave the house.
I remembered sitting beside Chloe in the dentist’s waiting room, wondering why our mother kept checking her phone.
“Why that one?” Ortiz asked.
“Because we came home early,” Chloe said. “Mom forgot her blue folder.”
The detective looked at us both.
“Are you comfortable with me checking a short section?”
I nodded.
So did Chloe.
Ortiz turned the volume low.
At first, there was only the hum of the heating system.
A drawer opening.
Footsteps.
Then Edric’s voice.
“Did she sign?”
My stomach tightened.
Brenda answered from farther away.
“Chloe wouldn’t.”
A chair scraped.
“I told you to keep them apart when you asked.”
“I did.”
“Then ask again.”
Ortiz stopped the recording.
Nobody moved.
Brenda should have been in the car with us.
Then I remembered.
She had sent us outside first.
Told us to wait with the doors locked.
We had sat there nearly twenty minutes.
“Keep going,” I whispered.
Ortiz studied my face.
I nodded again.
Brenda’s voice returned.
“Alan called. He wants to speak to them.”
Edric swore.
“I thought you handled him.”
“He’s asking questions about the trust.”
“Then tell him they’re asleep. Tell him anything.”
“He said he’ll call David’s lawyer.”
There was a long silence.
Then Edric said something that made Chloe’s fingers dig into my wrist.
“You said we had until their birthday.”
“I thought we did.”
“And now?”
A sound followed. Paper sliding over a table, perhaps. I couldn’t tell.
Then Brenda spoke.
“We need something in writing before anyone talks to them.”
Ortiz paused the file again.
This time, she closed the laptop halfway.
“That’s enough for now.”
“No,” I said. “There might be more.”
“There may be. We’ll preserve it.”
Her voice was calm, but she was already reaching for her phone.
“You’ve helped us find it. You don’t need to sit through the rest.”
She stepped outside.
Chloe stared at the closed laptop.
“Mom,” she said.
Only that.
Not a question.
Not even surprise.
Just the name of the person who should have stopped it.
I held her hand while she cried.
There were things I could forgive myself for not understanding.
Edric’s moods.
The money.
The papers.
But I had spent years trying to find one moment when our mother might have loved us enough to choose differently.
Now I knew she had been given those moments.
She had simply kept choosing him.
Near dawn, raised voices broke through the hallway.
Edric’s voice came first.
“I brought them here!”
A chair scraped outside.
Then a firm command I couldn’t make out.
Chloe pulled her blanket to her chest.
I stared at the door.
A nurse stepped inside and closed it behind her.
“You’re safe in this room,” she said.
“What’s happening?”
“The officers are dealing with it.”
Later, Ortiz told us Edric had been arrested in connection with the assault.
Hearing it did not feel the way I had imagined.
There was no sudden happiness.
My body still expected his footsteps.
Chloe still flinched when a cart struck the doorframe.
But that morning, when breakfast arrived, nobody made us ask permission to eat.
Chloe managed half a piece of toast.
I kept looking at it.
That small, ordinary thing felt enormous.
Brenda remained somewhere else in the hospital while investigators questioned her.
She asked to see us three times.
Three times, we said no.
The fourth time, she sent a message through a staff member.
“Tell them I love them.”
Chloe turned her face toward the window.
I said nothing.
By afternoon, exhaustion had begun to blur the edges of everything.
Then Miriam appeared in the doorway.
“Someone is here,” she said. “You can decide whether you want him to come in.”
Behind her stood Uncle Alan.
For a moment, he looked like a stranger wearing the face of someone I remembered.
His hair was shorter. There was gray at his temples. He carried a small travel bag with one strap twisted around his fist.
Then he saw us.
He stopped.
His mouth opened, but no words came.
Chloe reached for him first.
“Uncle Alan.”
He crossed the room and dropped his bag.
Before touching either of us, he asked, “Can I?”
That almost broke me more than anything else.
We nodded.
He bent carefully between our beds and put one arm around each of us.
“I’m here,” he said.
He repeated it until Chloe stopped asking whether he was real.
When he finally sat, he placed his phone on the blanket.
“I spoke to your father’s attorney. Her name is Evelyn Shaw.”
I remembered her vaguely.
Dark glasses. A warm handshake at Dad’s funeral. Brenda steering us away before we could speak.
“She’s coming tomorrow,” Alan said. “For now, she’s checking the trust records and preserving every message your mother sent her.”
“Can Mom take the money?” Chloe asked.
“Evelyn says your mother cannot simply take control of it. She’s reviewing the documents.”
I looked down.
“What if people believe what they wrote about me?”
Alan leaned forward.
“Then we show them what actually happened.”
He didn’t say it would be easy.
He said we.
A knock interrupted us.
Ortiz stood in the doorway with another detective.
She asked Miriam to stay, then pulled a chair close to the beds.
“We’ve recovered the phone from your bedroom,” she said.
My breath left me.
“It was still there?”
“Under the floorboard, where you told us.”
For the first time all day, I felt something close to relief.
Then I noticed she wasn’t smiling.
“What?”
“We’re still reviewing the recordings. There’s a conversation we need help placing in context.”
Alan sat straighter.
Ortiz looked at me.
“Faye, how much do you remember about the day your father died?”
The room went quiet.
“His car went off the road,” I said.
“What else were you told?”
“That he was tired. That it was raining.”
Ortiz nodded slowly.
“Did you know he had arranged to meet his attorney the following morning?”
I shook my head.
Alan’s hand closed around the edge of his chair.
“Lena,” the other detective said quietly.
She glanced at him, then back at us.
“A recording alone doesn’t establish what happened to your father,” she said. “But we need to check something we heard.”
“What did you hear?” I asked.
Nobody answered quickly enough.
“Please.”
Ortiz set her notebook on her knee.
“Your mother told Edric that David had discovered money was missing before he died.”
Alan stood.
“What?”
“And then?” I asked.
The detective hesitated.
Chloe reached for my hand.
“What did Edric say?”
Ortiz looked directly at me.
“He said, ‘He never made it to that appointment. Keep your voice down.’”
For years, I had believed the worst thing Edric ever did was enter our home after Dad died.
Now I needed to know whether he had been there before….
One Comment on “PART3: My stepfather h:ur:t my twin sister and me every single day because seeing us terrified gave him pleasure.”